Shut Up And Read

readingI loved my writing retreat over the last two weeks, but it’s left me feeling a bit unbalanced. No, not like that! Let me explain. All writing and no reading has left me feeling as if I need to follow up my writing retreat with a reading retreat. I love reading as much as I love writing. I’ve been reading intensively about creative research methods for the last couple of years, and now there’s lots of other research-related reading I want to do. But why can it be so hard to find the time?

I think it’s partly because reading isn’t seen as ‘doing something’, particularly by managers. Practitioners who I interviewed for my first research methods book gave varying reports of this. Some said their managers did value reading and would recommend journal articles they thought would be helpful for staff. Others said their managers did not value reading, particularly where staff had a busy caseload. Yet how can practice be evidence-based if staff and managers don’t have time to read the evidence?

Never having been an academic, I naively thought that this would be different in academia: that all academics would understand the importance of reading, and the act of reading would be valued as an essential part of an academic’s work. Sadly, I now know that this is not the case – or, at least, not everywhere.

I had an interesting discussion on Twitter last week with Inger Mewburn (aka @thesiswhisperer) and Annika Coughlin about why reading isn’t regarded as work in the same way as writing. (Inger pointed out there was a blog post in that, so here it is – part one, at least; she has promised to write a follow-up.) Maybe one reason is that reading is something you can do anywhere: on a sun lounger, during your commute, in the bath, on a plane. It’s portable, a time-filler, and that makes it seem like a leisure activity rather than work.

I think perhaps another reason is that reading is hard to quantify. You can say ‘I’ve read this article today’, but have you read every word? Did you understand it all? How much can you remember? I’m sure we’re all familiar with the phenomenon of reading something and retaining nothing, even straight after we’ve finished. The number of books or articles you’ve read is irrelevant if you didn’t understand or retain much of their contents. On the other hand, writing is very quantifiable, even if none of the 500 words you’ve just written will make it into your final draft.

Like writing, though, reading helps us think, and learn, and understand the world around us. Writing, thinking, and reading are the three pillars of the researcher’s working life – or they should be. As a researcher and a writer myself, I want people to read and use research and articles and books, because otherwise what’s the point of all my hard work? Some organisational cultures are much better at producing research than using it, which seems to me like a crazy waste of resources. We should use research first, and only produce more research when that’s really needed. But to use research, we have to… guess what? Wait for it… yep, we have to read.

TBR books Jun 15We all have to read. Including me. Here’s my current TBR pile – and it’s going to grow bigger, as I’ve just finished an online shopping spree to help me catch up on some topics of interest. I’ve made a commitment to reading at least one chapter a day, six days a week. And I’m not the only person who has been thinking along these lines; yesterday @tseenster of the Research Whisperer posted in a similar vein about her commitment to read at least two journal articles a day.

I’ve been wondering for a while why people are so keen on ‘shut up and write’ sessions, yet nobody runs ‘shut up and read’ sessions. And why do we have an #acwri hashtag on Twitter, but not an #acread hashtag? If we, as researchers and writers, can’t make reading a priority, then we can’t expect other people to read our work either. And that would be a sorry state of affairs. So maybe it’s time for us all to start talking about reading, sharing what we read, and generally telling the world that reading is both important and enjoyable.

7 thoughts on “Shut Up And Read

  1. A lovely post, Helen. I’m not sure if you have the #acwri/#acread bug or the retreat bug!

    As well as being an English teacher, onto whose DNA is grafted a deep belief in the power of reading, I am a reader. It’s how I absorb information. My reading skills are much more effective than my listening skills; don’t sign me up for #shutupandlisten!

    Yet ‘I read 10,000 words today!’ is less tangible and less quantifiable than having written words that can be counted. You mention that reading has different levels of quality, but so does writing. In both cases, more words aren’t necessarily better words.

    I like the idea of a sun-filled reading retreat. Quiet outdoor spot (hammock, bench, rug, table, sandy beach), stack of post it notes, pile of books. Sounds like terribly hard intellectual work! But then, I am a firm believer in choosing to work in spaces which makes thinking, reading or writing seem like holiday luxuriating: .


    Liked by 1 person

  2. Excellent post!

    There is a hash tag – #365papers – which is all about reading 1 paper per day and tweeting about it. Some are opting to read 1 paper per workday (5 days instead of 7) to maintain a realistic and healthy work/life balance.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. You put a lot of ideas together that have been wandering around in my brain; thanks for helping me to clarify one of the reasons why reading is so challenging, or at least challenging to talk about–it is tough to clearly measure, and as a result we at time struggle with making sense of it when discussing it with others.

    This really helps me with a blog post I have been struggling with all week . . .

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: Web Pickings

  5. Pingback: Slow down you move too fast – Literature reviews | annie's blogette

  6. Pingback: Making Reading Visible – upalonger

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.